katherinebarlow
replied to your post
“katherinebarlow
replied to your post “Hello I am here to ask for…”
I think it’s valid for characters who have in lived a lot of places to have an accent that reflects those influences that doesn’t sound exactly like one accent from those specific places. (And there are regional variations!) In the book, he sounds Australian and a tiny bit Eastern European. I think that the main thing is for the actors to really commit, and from the little bits I’ve heard, they did. I also have my issues with Erik Singer, but that’s neither here nor there.
Yes yes yes Accents Chat!
The regional variations thing is something I think about a lot. I wonder if many people’s knee-jerk reaction against actors’ accents is because they’re just comparing it to one single gestalt they have. I remember many years ago a coworker’s friend bemoaning that Karen Gillan’s Scottish accent sounded fake, when she is in fact…Scottish. But she’s from Inverness, not Glasgow, so sounds different from say, James McAvoy. But these are both Scottish accents!
Oooooh wait, I’m nervous to have my husband spoken ill of, but like…what are the deets on Erik Singer.